Where to start with the SRA's AML findings: learnings with Eloise Butterworth of All Things Risk
The SRA’s AML annual report is easy to read and easy to agree with. Working out what to do about it is harder.
That was the subject of the webinar we hosted on 18 November 2026 with Eloise Butterworth, founder of All Things Risk. Eloise audits law firms’ AML frameworks and is a former law firm compliance manager, and she spent the hour on what a firm should do with the report rather than on what it says. Her advice was not to take on everything at once. Pick one place to start. For most firms, that is the firm-wide risk assessment.
This post sets out what we took from the session as five steps, in the order a firm would work through them. If you would rather hear it from Eloise, the replay and the self-evaluation handout she built for the session are here.
- Be honest about where the firm is
- Begin with the firm-wide risk assessment
- Ask whether you would know
- Review files as if you want to find something
- Move people’s time to where the risk is
1. Be honest about where the firm is
On the headline numbers, the profession has had a good year. The SRA’s AML annual report 2025/26, published in October 2026, covers 6 April 2025 to 5 April 2026, and its foreword describes “substantial progress”. The share of firms the SRA found fully compliant rose from 13.4% to 22%.
Eloise’s first move was to turn that number round. If 22% of firms are fully compliant, roughly four in five are not. Most of those sit in what she called the amber zone: partially compliant, “neither compliant nor non-compliant”, and unsure what would move them out of it.
The documents also look better than the practice. Firm-wide risk assessments were compliant at 60% of firms and policies, controls and procedures at 54%, both well up on the year before. But as Eloise put it, “getting the documents right on paper is actually easier than getting them working in practice”.
So the first step is an honest look. Where a firm starts depends, in her words, on “where you are honestly at”, and not on “where you probably told the board that you were at”. And “I don’t know” is “a valid answer”, because it tells the firm what to find out next.
2. Begin with the firm-wide risk assessment
Of everything the report covers, Eloise pointed firms to one document first. Regulation 18 of the Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, the MLRs, requires every firm in scope to have a written firm-wide risk assessment, and the rest of the framework depends on it. The policies exist to mitigate the risks it identifies, and every client and matter risk assessment is supposed to take it into account. As she put it, “you can’t mitigate what you’re not identifying”.
The SRA’s findings suggest many firms have not yet got it right. Six of the 937 firms it reviewed had no firm-wide risk assessment at all, and 39 of the reports it received during the year concerned a firm without one. About a third of the assessments it did review were only partially compliant.
What surprised Eloise was where they fell short. She had expected something time-sensitive, such as a sectoral risk assessment update that had not been carried across. Instead the most common weakness was transaction risk. In the SRA’s words, “many firms failed to assess the nature and value of transactions they typically undertake”. Next came product and service risk, where firms had not accurately described the in-scope work they do.
These are foundations, which suggests documents that were unsteady when first written and have not been revisited since. Eloise sees the same in her audits: risk assessments that concentrate on the work the firm doesn’t do rather than the work it does.
That makes the job smaller than it sounds. Nobody needs to reopen the whole document. Take the transaction section alone and ask three questions. What does a usual transaction look like at this firm, by size and by structure? Does the list of services match the website? What data sits behind each conclusion?
The SRA says the strongest assessments “demonstrated a clear understanding of the firm’s business model, client base and transactional activity”, and several drew on management information such as high-risk clients, overseas instructions and transaction values. If the firm cannot produce that data, that is useful to know.
3. Ask whether you would know
With the firm-wide risk assessment in order, attention moves from the document to the files. Here Eloise offered one test that works for every finding in the report. The SRA found no client and matter risk assessment, or an incomplete one, on 9% of files. If that were true at your firm, would you know? And how: because you asked people, because of a file review sample that is in reality quite small, or because you can report on it?
The answer depends on who does the onboarding, and she covered both models. Where fee earners complete the risk assessment themselves, the process has to work for the people filling it in as well as for compliance, and the risk is inconsistency. Her example was a corporate team screening one set of people for sanctions on a corporate client while the commercial property team screens another.
Whichever model the firm runs, fee earners or a central team, it also has to decide how judgement is recorded. How should scrutiny of source of funds be written up, in what detail, and where is it saved? When Eloise asks where that evidence would sit on a file, firms often say it might be in the risk assessment, or in an email, or in a compliance subfolder.
“If you don’t even set out how you want your teams to do it,” she asked, “how are you then going to build that report to make sure you have the visibility that it’s happening?”
One attendee asked what to do when the firm has no way of checking for a risk assessment without opening the file. Eloise’s reply was that they are not alone, and that nobody with 8,000 or 10,000 open files wants to go through them all. Digitising the risk assessment is one of the conversations she has most often, because a Word document saved in a case management system will struggle to give the oversight now expected. Compliance technology providers, Legl among them, have built for this class of problem: a client and matter Risk Assessment completed digitally, so that completion and risk ratings can be seen across the firm rather than file by file.
4. Review files as if you want to find something
Reporting shows whether a control happened. It takes a file review to show whether it was done well, and this is where Eloise thinks most firms can improve without adding work. Her message was that “it’s not about doing more, it’s about doing it better”, and her instruction was direct: “I would like you to look at your files like you actually want to find something.”
In practice that means asking sharper questions. Many file review forms ask whether a client and matter risk assessment is on the file. Eloise would ask five things instead. Was it completed at the right time? Were the relevant risk indicators picked up and recorded? Does it contain narrative, or only ticks? Is the rating aligned with the firm-wide risk assessment? Does it make sense?
The SRA’s findings explain why. It judged risk assessments ineffective at 36% of firms and disagreed with the recorded rating on 10% of files, so a form on the file is no longer the test. The same goes for screening, where a report on the file does not show that the right searches were run against the right people and entities, or that anyone considered the results. And a file marked “non-compliant” with no reason attached gives nobody anything to act on.
Sharper does not mean longer. One firm told her its file review form ran to 14 pages. Where the data shows the firm is sound, she would dial the checking down and spend the effort where the SRA says firms like yours struggle.
5. Move people’s time to where the risk is
All of this takes time that compliance teams do not have, and Eloise was plain about that: “No one’s got spare resource.” Her answer was not to look for savings but to move the time the firm already spends. If a control is working but taking up a lot of people’s time, let systems do the heavy lifting there, so that people can go “where risk indicates that you need it most”.
That only works if the firm understands what its technology does. The SRA found that almost 93% of firms use technology for customer due diligence, and that just under half (48%) say they often test it for accuracy. When Eloise asks firms how their tools work, the confident answers are “often not quite true”: how fuzzy matching works, how aliases are treated, who receives a monitoring alert and how often.
Pick one step and finish it
None of this has to be done at once, and Eloise was clear that it should not be. Her suggestion was to choose one action from whichever step exposes the most, give it a date, and make it “something you can knock on the head by Christmas”.
There is a reason not to wait. One attendee asked whether a firm inspected three years ago should expect another visit. Eloise knows of firms that have been visited more than once in that time, and whenever the next review comes it will be carried out with “today’s lenses, and today’s lenses are not the same as what we were looking at in 2023”. That will still be true when AML supervision passes to the FCA, for which no date had been confirmed as of 19 November 2026.
It is also too late to start once the notice letter arrives. A firm that rewrites its firm-wide risk assessment between the letter and the deadline should expect a good assessor to notice, and to ask for the version that was in place before.
Eloise expects the same four findings to lead next year’s report: firm-wide risk assessments, policies, client and matter risk assessments, and source of funds. The firms that move out of the amber zone will be the ones that picked one thing and finished it.
The full session and Eloise’s self-evaluation handout are available on demand, and the handout takes under half an hour to complete. If you would like to talk through how your firm’s risk assessments could be reported on rather than sampled, Legl’s UK team is happy to have that conversation.





